Organization and Management Theory OMT

  • 1.  Article On Analytic Thinking

    Posted 09-20-2010 19:08
    Dear colleagues,

    I'm developing a first-semester MBA course on different thinking skills and
    looking for a core reading on "analytic thinking" that introduces basic
    concepts such as hypothesis development and testing, root cause analysis,
    etc. I'm hoping to find either an article (preferred) or a book chapter that
    is practical and readable, yet challenging for MBA students.

    Thank you in advance for any leads,

    Ingo Holzinger
    Schulich School of Business
    York University


  • 2.  Article On Analytic Thinking

    Posted 09-20-2010 19:35
    In a world where design thinking is what matters,
    this seems a giant step backward.

    gordon

    ++++++++++++++++++++++++++
    Gordon E Dehler, PhD
    Dept of Mgt & Entrepreneurship
    School of Business
    College of Charleston
    5 Liberty Street
    Charleston, SC 29424
    843.953.6664
    dehlerg@cofc.edu
    ++++++++++++++++++++++++++
    We need more Fruitcakes in the world;
    Less bakers.
    - Jimmy Buffett in Fruitcakes




    ________________________________

    From: Organization and Management Theory Division Listserv on behalf of Ingo Holzinger
    Sent: Mon 9/20/2010 7:08 PM
    To: OMT@AOMLISTS.PACE.EDU
    Subject: [OMT] Article On Analytic Thinking



    Dear colleagues,

    I'm developing a first-semester MBA course on different thinking skills and
    looking for a core reading on "analytic thinking" that introduces basic
    concepts such as hypothesis development and testing, root cause analysis,
    etc. I'm hoping to find either an article (preferred) or a book chapter that
    is practical and readable, yet challenging for MBA students.

    Thank you in advance for any leads,

    Ingo Holzinger
    Schulich School of Business
    York University


  • 3.  Article On Analytic Thinking

    Posted 09-20-2010 19:35
    Hi there,

    Attached is a suggestion that might be worth considering as a resource for your course alongside a more formal piece on analytical thinking. .

    Best,


    Craig Prichard
    Tari Whakahaere Kaipakihi ,
    Te Kunenga Ki Purehuroa
    Pouaka Motuhake 11-222
    Te Papaioea, Aotearoa
    School of Management 214
    Massey University, Private Bag 11-222
    Palmerston North, New Zealand
    Skype: Craig.Prichard.kiwi
    Phone: 0064 (0) 6 356-9099 ext. 2244
    Email: [c.prichard@massey.ac.nz]

    Critical Management Studies Division
    Academy of Management

    Management Learning
    Organization
     
    OIL (Organization, Identity and Locality) Network

    Asia-Pacific Researchers in Organization Studies
    14th biennial Conference
    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~



    -----Original Message-----
    From: Organization and Management Theory Division Listserv [mailto:OMT@AOMLISTS.PACE.EDU] On Behalf Of Ingo Holzinger
    Sent: Tuesday, 21 September 2010 11:08 a.m.
    To: OMT@AOMLISTS.PACE.EDU
    Subject: [OMT] Article On Analytic Thinking

    Dear colleagues,

    I'm developing a first-semester MBA course on different thinking skills and
    looking for a core reading on "analytic thinking" that introduces basic
    concepts such as hypothesis development and testing, root cause analysis,
    etc. I'm hoping to find either an article (preferred) or a book chapter that
    is practical and readable, yet challenging for MBA students.

    Thank you in advance for any leads,

    Ingo Holzinger
    Schulich School of Business
    York University


  • 4.  Article On Analytic Thinking

    Posted 09-20-2010 19:53
    Dear Ingo Holzinger

    I use Edward de Bono's work (the 60 Cort Thinking Skills modules ) that
    address both lateral and critical thinking skills. These cognitive skills
    map nicely into the updated Bloom's taxonomy.

    I first used them when I was the Director of the Idea Lab at the DX in
    Toronto back in the 1980s.

    I now teach at the new MA program in Strategic Foresight and Innovation
    (SFI) at OCAD university

    Walter Derzko
    Smart Economy
    Toronto
    wderzko@pathcom.com
    Walter.derzko@utoronto.ca
    416-819-9667
    http://smarteconomy.typepad.com


    -----Original Message-----
    From: Organization and Management Theory Division Listserv
    [mailto:OMT@AOMLISTS.PACE.EDU] On Behalf Of Ingo Holzinger
    Sent: Monday, September 20, 2010 7:08 PM
    To: OMT@AOMLISTS.PACE.EDU
    Subject: [OMT] Article On Analytic Thinking

    Dear colleagues,

    I'm developing a first-semester MBA course on different thinking skills and
    looking for a core reading on "analytic thinking" that introduces basic
    concepts such as hypothesis development and testing, root cause analysis,
    etc. I'm hoping to find either an article (preferred) or a book chapter that
    is practical and readable, yet challenging for MBA students.

    Thank you in advance for any leads,

    Ingo Holzinger
    Schulich School of Business
    York University


  • 5.  Article On Analytic Thinking

    Posted 09-21-2010 09:07
    may I respectfully suggest looking at the material at http://remedy101.com

    48D3A3F9C27FDC419AF2B1BBD8ACB76C0107784C@EXCHMBX2.COUGARS.INT" type="cite">


    ________________________________

    From: Organization and Management Theory Division Listserv on behalf of Ingo Holzinger
    Sent: Mon 9/20/2010 7:08 PM
    To: OMT@AOMLISTS.PACE.EDU
    Subject: [OMT] Article On Analytic Thinking



    Dear colleagues,

    I'm developing a first-semester MBA course on different thinking skills and
    looking for a core reading on "analytic thinking" that introduces basic
    concepts such as hypothesis development and testing, root cause analysis,
    etc. I'm hoping to find either an article (preferred) or a book chapter that
    is practical and readable, yet challenging for MBA students.

    Thank you in advance for any leads,

    Ingo Holzinger
    Schulich School of Business
    York University

    --


  • 6.  Article On Analytic Thinking

    Posted 09-21-2010 09:15
    I wouldn't imagine this backward(s)ness would be true.

    Even from a design perspective, there is (or at least should be) a
    recognition for the toggling between or at least the mixing of the
    assumed extremes that are analyzing and creating. Isn't a mindful
    mixture of these things what designing is?

    Otherwise, quite frankly, the design perspective will just become
    another fad--a function of a monolithic approach to an honestly
    complex problem.

    In fact, it would seem that from the perspective of strategy (or
    strategizing, if you will) as a process, the inclusion of analytical
    features seems paramount to learning opportunities. "We designed in
    anticipation of X, but got what seems to be Z. How or why did this
    happen?"

    There is an HBR article on designing business experiments. It might
    serve the "analytical" purpose here.

    David Touve
    just some guy who tries to teach strategy

    On Sep 20, 2010, at 19:34, "Dehler, Gordon E" <DehlerG@COFC.EDU> wrote:

    > In a world where design thinking is what matters,
    > this seems a giant step backward.
    >
    > gordon
    >
    > ++++++++++++++++++++++++++
    > Gordon E Dehler, PhD
    > Dept of Mgt & Entrepreneurship
    > School of Business
    > College of Charleston
    > 5 Liberty Street
    > Charleston, SC 29424
    > 843.953.6664
    > dehlerg@cofc.edu
    > ++++++++++++++++++++++++++
    > We need more Fruitcakes in the world;
    > Less bakers.
    > - Jimmy Buffett in Fruitcakes
    >
    >
    >
    >
    > ________________________________
    >
    > From: Organization and Management Theory Division Listserv on behalf of Ingo Holzinger
    > Sent: Mon 9/20/2010 7:08 PM
    > To: OMT@AOMLISTS.PACE.EDU
    > Subject: [OMT] Article On Analytic Thinking
    >
    >
    >
    > Dear colleagues,
    >
    > I'm developing a first-semester MBA course on different thinking skills and
    > looking for a core reading on "analytic thinking" that introduces basic
    > concepts such as hypothesis development and testing, root cause analysis,
    > etc. I'm hoping to find either an article (preferred) or a book chapter that
    > is practical and readable, yet challenging for MBA students.
    >
    > Thank you in advance for any leads,
    >
    > Ingo Holzinger
    > Schulich School of Business
    > York University


  • 7.  Article On Analytic Thinking

    Posted 09-21-2010 09:20
    Could always try Hunter (2006) critical inquiry, 33, 78-112. it's a good counterbalance.

    >>> "Dehler, Gordon E" <DehlerG@COFC.EDU> 21/09/2010 00:34 >>>
    In a world where design thinking is what matters,
    this seems a giant step backward.

    gordon

    ++++++++++++++++++++++++++
    Gordon E Dehler, PhD
    Dept of Mgt & Entrepreneurship
    School of Business
    College of Charleston
    5 Liberty Street
    Charleston, SC 29424
    843.953.6664
    dehlerg@cofc.edu
    ++++++++++++++++++++++++++
    We need more Fruitcakes in the world;
    Less bakers.
    - Jimmy Buffett in Fruitcakes




    ________________________________

    From: Organization and Management Theory Division Listserv on behalf of Ingo Holzinger
    Sent: Mon 9/20/2010 7:08 PM
    To: OMT@AOMLISTS.PACE.EDU
    Subject: [OMT] Article On Analytic Thinking



    Dear colleagues,

    I'm developing a first-semester MBA course on different thinking skills and
    looking for a core reading on "analytic thinking" that introduces basic
    concepts such as hypothesis development and testing, root cause analysis,
    etc. I'm hoping to find either an article (preferred) or a book chapter that
    is practical and readable, yet challenging for MBA students.

    Thank you in advance for any leads,

    Ingo Holzinger
    Schulich School of Business
    York University


  • 8.  Article On Analytic Thinking

    Posted 09-21-2010 09:55

    Hi Ingo,

     

    I really like the work of Jeanne Liedtka at Darden, and find her note (Darden UVA-BP-0486: Using Hypothesis-driven thinking in strategy consulting). Here is the opening quote from that resource:

     

    That's what we're good at-developing good hypotheses about a business situation. When you do a business case, you don't have to be hypothesis-driven, because you've got five or ten pages of data and anybody can process that much in a relatively limited period of time. We have all the data in the world, and it's really hard to get, and so we need to make some judgments about what we think is going to be important and what's not.... Our challenge is to say which questions to start with and figure how to collect the data to answer them.

     

                                                              -Senior Partner, Bain & Company

     

    Here is a link to it on SSRN:  http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=907959

     

    Best, Mason

     

    Mason A. Carpenter

    Professor and M. Keith Weikel Chair in Leadership

    Associate Dean, Enterprise MBA Programs

    (608) 262-9449 o

    mcarpenter@bus.wisc.edu e

    http://research3.bus.wisc.edu/course/view.php?id=139

    strategyprof.edublogs.org/

    http://www.linkedin.com/in/masoncarpenter

    http://courses.bus.wisc.edu/

    http://ssrn.com/author=209269

    P Please consider the environment before printing this email

     

     



    Dear colleagues,

    I'm developing a first-semester MBA course on different thinking skills and
    looking for a core reading on "analytic thinking" that introduces basic
    concepts such as hypothesis development and testing, root cause analysis,
    etc. I'm hoping to find either an article (preferred) or a book chapter that
    is practical and readable, yet challenging for MBA students.

    Thank you in advance for any leads,

    Ingo Holzinger
    Schulich School of Business
    York University

     

    --



  • 9.  Article On Analytic Thinking

    Posted 09-21-2010 11:15
    Ingo,

    This is a small book that I can recommend.

    Asking the Right Questions: A Guide to Critical Thinking (8th Edition)
    Neil Browne & Stuart M. Keeley (Prentice Hall)

    The introductory pages (14-18, available online at Amazon LookInside)
    of a book titled Analytical Narratives, describe the process authors
    used for the cases they present in the book. They identify the
    following 5 questions as their process of developing the 'analytical
    narratives' they present. It is a practice-oriented approach rather
    than the theory of 'analytical thinking', so it may be a good
    illustrative way to explore the topic.

    Do the assumptions fit the fact, as they are known?
    Do conclusions follow from the premises?
    Do its implications find confirmation in the data?
    How well does the theory stand up by comparision with other explanations?
    How general is the explanation? Does it apply to other cases?

    Analytic Narratives
    Robert H. Bates (Author), Avner Greif (Author), Margaret Levi
    (Author), Jean-Laurent Rosenthal (Author), Barry R Weingast (Author),
    Barry R. Weingast (Author)

    best,
    Jyoti Bachani
    Assistant Professor
    Saint Mary's College of California